Convergence, Ahead of Print.
This article seeks to understand how app delivery workers construct their collective identity through the digital platforms of YouTube and TikTok. Said identity construction occurs in the context of the social controversy surrounding their status as workers without labor rights or as independent partners of digital platforms. To this end, we collected 977 videos and their metadata and analyzed them via cross-platform digital methods. The findings reveal that app delivery workers construct their collective identity through the interplay of two factors. The first is the identity narratives created by delivery workers as video bloggers. The second is the recognition narratives created by different associated actors, such as accountants, media, universities and research centers, and content creators. Through these interactions, the narrative of delivery workers as independent partners acquires more algorithmic strength and visibility than those that discuss their status as employees and their lack of labor rights. Audiovisual technology also works as an instrument to reach individual agency and face the precariousness of daily life.
New territories for fan studies: The insurrection, QAnon, Donald Trump and fandom
Convergence, Ahead of Print.
The following roundtable is a recorded and edited discussion between four fan studies researchers that took place in March 2022. Having all worked with QAnon and the insurrection in the context of fan studies, our discussion took its departure from the US insurrection on January 6, 2021, as QAnon fans, Trump fans, and other right-wing groups stormed the US Capitol building while live-streaming their endeavor to social media. The discussion draws out some main perspectives that may guide our future thinking in the context of fandom, complicity, and politics and points toward new cultural and social territories for research into fandom and fan practices. Centrally, as fandom enters into the domain of politics and conspiracy theories, it seems increasingly unfruitful to distinguish between fan practices and participatory culture. Instead, participatory culture’s primary mode seems to be deeply driven by fan practices, that is, textual poaching and enunciative and textual productivity (Jenkins, 2013; Fiske, 1992). Instead, understanding this amalgamation of fan practices into other social domains can help us make sense of current phenomena in the seeming growth of conspiracy theory communities and right-wing movements alike. Participatory culture is a source of great creativity, playfulness, and mobilization of social and political movements, but, as Jenkins pointed out as early as 2006 “has benefited third parties, revolutionaries, reactionaries, and racists alike” (Jenkins, 2006, p. 221). In some instances, it seems that these online communities are driven by fan practices, in other instances fan communities are weaponized in order to serve a political agenda. While research into fandom and politics (see Hinck, 2019; Jenkins et al., 2020, Sandvoss, 2012, etc.) and toxic cultures (Proctor et. al., 2018) is certainly not new, it seems that the current transmedial landscapes drive participation and complicity in very specific ways that fan studies would do well to focus on in the coming years.
The following roundtable is a recorded and edited discussion between four fan studies researchers that took place in March 2022. Having all worked with QAnon and the insurrection in the context of fan studies, our discussion took its departure from the US insurrection on January 6, 2021, as QAnon fans, Trump fans, and other right-wing groups stormed the US Capitol building while live-streaming their endeavor to social media. The discussion draws out some main perspectives that may guide our future thinking in the context of fandom, complicity, and politics and points toward new cultural and social territories for research into fandom and fan practices. Centrally, as fandom enters into the domain of politics and conspiracy theories, it seems increasingly unfruitful to distinguish between fan practices and participatory culture. Instead, participatory culture’s primary mode seems to be deeply driven by fan practices, that is, textual poaching and enunciative and textual productivity (Jenkins, 2013; Fiske, 1992). Instead, understanding this amalgamation of fan practices into other social domains can help us make sense of current phenomena in the seeming growth of conspiracy theory communities and right-wing movements alike. Participatory culture is a source of great creativity, playfulness, and mobilization of social and political movements, but, as Jenkins pointed out as early as 2006 “has benefited third parties, revolutionaries, reactionaries, and racists alike” (Jenkins, 2006, p. 221). In some instances, it seems that these online communities are driven by fan practices, in other instances fan communities are weaponized in order to serve a political agenda. While research into fandom and politics (see Hinck, 2019; Jenkins et al., 2020, Sandvoss, 2012, etc.) and toxic cultures (Proctor et. al., 2018) is certainly not new, it seems that the current transmedial landscapes drive participation and complicity in very specific ways that fan studies would do well to focus on in the coming years.
‘I have controlled so much’: Discourse of prison violence
Discourse &Society, Volume 34, Issue 6, Page 691-711, November 2023.
Prison violence has been considered a threat to not only the safety of inmates, staff, and visitors but the day-to-day functioning of the prisons, and therefore is strictly forbidden and immediately punished. However, some inmates still turn to violence, which raises doubts about whether these inmates are naturally violent and impossible to change. This paper, based on in-depth interviews with 27 inmates who have committed violence and remained in solitary confinement in prisons in Zhejiang Province, China, examines how the inmates make sense of and describe their violent experiences. It is found that these inmates make efforts to construct their victims as deserving, acts as controlled, and punishment as acceptable through employing discursive strategies such as resorting to traditional values, conditional sentences, and repetition. In so doing, these inmates seek to redefine who they are not, how they should not be treated and what prison life should not be like. This paper could open up ways of better understanding why violence could be reduced but impossible to be eliminated completely in the prison context.
Prison violence has been considered a threat to not only the safety of inmates, staff, and visitors but the day-to-day functioning of the prisons, and therefore is strictly forbidden and immediately punished. However, some inmates still turn to violence, which raises doubts about whether these inmates are naturally violent and impossible to change. This paper, based on in-depth interviews with 27 inmates who have committed violence and remained in solitary confinement in prisons in Zhejiang Province, China, examines how the inmates make sense of and describe their violent experiences. It is found that these inmates make efforts to construct their victims as deserving, acts as controlled, and punishment as acceptable through employing discursive strategies such as resorting to traditional values, conditional sentences, and repetition. In so doing, these inmates seek to redefine who they are not, how they should not be treated and what prison life should not be like. This paper could open up ways of better understanding why violence could be reduced but impossible to be eliminated completely in the prison context.
“A radical point of view”: The discursive construction of the political identity of student activists
Discourse &Society, Volume 34, Issue 6, Page 772-788, November 2023.
Recently there has been renewed interest in the intersection of identity and epistemics in social interaction, yet epistemics has still rarely been analyzed in political identity construction. This paper combines research on identity from a sociocultural linguistic perspective with epistemics using Conversation Analysis. The focus here is on understanding how a small group of student activists construct their shared political identities through epistemic stances towards their academic majors and career goals. Through a discourse analytic study of conversational data among these activists, I demonstrate the validity of the relationality principle of identity in accounting for how identities are constructed as related to one another. Furthermore, I examine the relational process of authentication in epistemic stances to legitimate claims to knowledge regarding political and academic identities, as well as alignment of stances in building group solidarity and shared political identity.
Recently there has been renewed interest in the intersection of identity and epistemics in social interaction, yet epistemics has still rarely been analyzed in political identity construction. This paper combines research on identity from a sociocultural linguistic perspective with epistemics using Conversation Analysis. The focus here is on understanding how a small group of student activists construct their shared political identities through epistemic stances towards their academic majors and career goals. Through a discourse analytic study of conversational data among these activists, I demonstrate the validity of the relationality principle of identity in accounting for how identities are constructed as related to one another. Furthermore, I examine the relational process of authentication in epistemic stances to legitimate claims to knowledge regarding political and academic identities, as well as alignment of stances in building group solidarity and shared political identity.
Book review: Balwant Singh Mehta and Ishwar Chandra Awasthi, Women and Labour Market Dynamics: New Insights and Evidences
Indian Journal of Gender Studies, Volume 30, Issue 2, Page 240-243, June 2023.
Balwant Singh Mehta and Ishwar Chandra Awasthi, Women and Labour Market Dynamics: New Insights and Evidences (Springer, 2019), 178 pp., GBP 59.99, ISBN 9789811390562 (Hardcover).
Balwant Singh Mehta and Ishwar Chandra Awasthi, Women and Labour Market Dynamics: New Insights and Evidences (Springer, 2019), 178 pp., GBP 59.99, ISBN 9789811390562 (Hardcover).
Book review: Ajantha Subramanian, The Caste of Merit: Engineering Education in India
Indian Journal of Gender Studies, Volume 30, Issue 2, Page 243-246, June 2023.
Ajantha Subramanian, The Caste of Merit: Engineering Education in India (Harvard University Press, 2019), 374 pp., GBP 39.95, ISBN 9780674987883 (Hardbound).
Ajantha Subramanian, The Caste of Merit: Engineering Education in India (Harvard University Press, 2019), 374 pp., GBP 39.95, ISBN 9780674987883 (Hardbound).
Book review: Navaneetha Mokkil and Shefali Jha (Eds.), Thinking Women: A Feminist Reader
Indian Journal of Gender Studies, Volume 30, Issue 2, Page 236-239, June 2023.
Navaneetha Mokkil and Shefali Jha (Eds.), Thinking Women: A Feminist Reader (Kolkata Stree Publication, 2019), 528 pp., ₹999, ISBN 978-8190676007 (Paperback).
Navaneetha Mokkil and Shefali Jha (Eds.), Thinking Women: A Feminist Reader (Kolkata Stree Publication, 2019), 528 pp., ₹999, ISBN 978-8190676007 (Paperback).
Book review: Kalpana Kannabiran, Law, Justice and Human Rights in India: Short Reflections
Indian Journal of Gender Studies, Volume 30, Issue 2, Page 250-254, June 2023.
Kalpana Kannabiran, Law, Justice and Human Rights in India: Short Reflections (Orient BlackSwan, 2021), 416 pp., ₹1,500, ISBN 9789354421105 (Paperback).
Kalpana Kannabiran, Law, Justice and Human Rights in India: Short Reflections (Orient BlackSwan, 2021), 416 pp., ₹1,500, ISBN 9789354421105 (Paperback).
Book review: Manjima Bhattacharjya, Intimate City
Indian Journal of Gender Studies, Volume 30, Issue 2, Page 254-257, June 2023.
Manjima Bhattacharjya, Intimate City. Zubaan Publishers, 2021, 240 pages, ₹420 (Ebook), ISBN: 9789390514366
Manjima Bhattacharjya, Intimate City. Zubaan Publishers, 2021, 240 pages, ₹420 (Ebook), ISBN: 9789390514366
Book review: Tamizhini, In the Shadow of a Sword: The Memoir of a Woman Leader in the LTTE
Indian Journal of Gender Studies, Volume 30, Issue 2, Page 246-250, June 2023.
Tamizhini, In the Shadow of a Sword: The Memoir of a Woman Leader in the LTTE (Yoda Press, 2021), 197 pp., ₹495, ISBN 9789353886837 (Paperback).
Tamizhini, In the Shadow of a Sword: The Memoir of a Woman Leader in the LTTE (Yoda Press, 2021), 197 pp., ₹495, ISBN 9789353886837 (Paperback).